No. Saying "that's a good question" once in an interview is not a sin. Saying it over and over is a habit worth breaking, and a short direct answer beats it either way. I know that puts me at odds with some of my own profession.
Someone in a recent workshop asked me if it was a mistake. The phrase had come up in the room a number of times that day, so it was a fair thing to ask. Here is what I told them.
Where the rule comes from
There are media trainers who get annoyed when somebody says, "That's a good question." The logic goes like this: everybody says it, it sounds like a stall, and it wastes two seconds of airtime.
That logic is not entirely wrong. Sometimes it is a stall. A person hears a hard question and reaches for the phrase to buy a moment to think. Sometimes, though, it is a sincere reaction: oh, that is a really good question.
I do not have a problem with it when it happens one time in an interview. What I notice is when someone says it over and over. A phrase repeated on every answer becomes noise, and it starts to sound like you are not listening to what is being asked.
A lot of old-school rules get too much attention
This is one of several rules in older media training that certain trainers focus on unnecessarily. I am not against rules. I am against spending your limited practice time on the small ones.
Here is a test. Think of the last time you watched a guest on TV give a strong answer, and then someone later told you it was a terrible answer because they said "good question" first. That conversation never happens. Nobody was probably paying attention to the phrase if they got what they wanted from the answer.
When the phrase is doing real work
Someone in the room pointed out that a tough question can leave you thinking, so "that's a good question" gains you a bit of time, and you can process the answer before you bring it. They are right, and I would not take that from anyone. Buying a second to think is legitimate.
The question is whether there is a better way to use that second. There is.
What I would do instead
Go straight to a short answer. I teach this in what I call the answer system. You write out the answers you wish you could say, group them under a few one-word headings, and walk in knowing those words so your brain knows where you might be going. Then the short answer deals with the question first.
A short answer can be "yes, that is a big problem." It can be "no." It can be "I don't know, but here is what I do know." Or, if you would rather not go anywhere near the topic, "time will tell." The short answer ties a bow on the question, and then you get to go where you want to go.
On the day this came up, I realized that when the participants were doing that well, I did not actually hear anyone say "that's a good question." They went right to their short answer. The phrase did not appear because it was not needed.
Three ways to answer a hard question
- The honest pause. Take a beat. Silence feels long to you and short to everyone else.
- The short answer. Deal with the question in a few words, then move to your point.
- The compliment, once. If it really is a good question, say so, and say something real about why.
Why the pause beats the phrase
When executives are nervous, the silence before an answer feels like a canyon. To the viewer or the reporter it is a beat. It reads as thought. A stock phrase said to cover the gap can actually sound more nervous than the quiet it replaced.
That is the reason I would rather you practise the short answer and the pause than spend hours policing one phrase. The first two change how you sound in every interview. The third changes it in a few seconds of one.
How to catch the habit
You will not hear it yourself in the moment. Record a practice interview and count. If the phrase shows up once, leave it alone. If it opens half of your answers, replace it with the short answer. Do not swap in a different filler, such as "great question," "interesting," or "well, look." That is the same habit with a new label.
If you want other ways to practise answering, the guide to tough media interview questions goes further, and the piece on bridging explains how to move from the short answer to your own message.
What to do next
Record yourself answering five questions you expect to be asked. Count the filler phrases, and write a short answer for each one. If you would like feedback on your own recordings, get a quick quote and we can book a call.